Russia Seeks Security Guarantees as Its Military and Economic Resources Come Under Pressure

Russia Seeks Security Guarantees as Its Military and Economic Resources Come Under Pressure
Share

The Kremlin continues to pair demands for a fundamental change in Europe’s security order with diplomatic initiatives to shape the terms of a settlement. Moscow insists that Ukraine withdraw from the part of Donetsk region still under Kyiv’s control and demands written guarantees that NATO will not expand eastward. At the same time, it has proposed a humanitarian operation in Kostiantynivka, accompanied by a temporary ceasefire. By involving Washington and European capitals, Russia seeks to increase pressure on Kyiv and present itself as the side that controls the conflict’s course and the terms of its resolution.

However, recent developments point to growing constraints on Russia’s ability to sustain the war. Ukrainian strikes on oil, gas, and port infrastructure in Ust-Luga have demonstrated that key export facilities remain vulnerable to attacks deep inside Russian territory. Meanwhile, NATO’s engagement with the defence industry in Brussels reflects a shift towards the long-term expansion of production capacity, particularly in long-range precision weapons. Russia must increasingly allocate resources to sustain its offensive and protect infrastructure in its rear, while NATO countries are building up their industrial and technological capacity for a prolonged confrontation.

This contrast helps explain Moscow’s current diplomatic approach. As the material basis of Russian military power comes under increasing pressure, the Kremlin seeks to use negotiations to secure political restrictions on Ukraine and NATO, obtain operational pauses, and reduce the costs of continuing the war. Its diplomatic initiatives therefore reflect an attempt to preserve strategic advantages that Russia can no longer secure through military pressure alone.

Military Attrition and the Growing Vulnerability of Russian Infrastructure

Years of full-scale war have significantly reduced Russia’s inherited Soviet stocks of military equipment, which previously supported its numerical advantage. Losses at the front continue to deplete reserves of armoured vehicles and artillery. At the same time, the growing reach of Ukrainian strikes forces the Russian command to redistribute air defence systems across a much wider area and spend increasingly valuable interceptor missiles to protect military and economic facilities far from the front line.

The loss of radar systems and air defence complexes creates additional problems. Radars provide the detection and tracking capabilities required for interception and help coordinate different elements of air defence. Their destruction therefore affects the performance of the wider system, rather than just reducing the number of available installations. Replacing these systems requires specialized electronics, access to components affected by sanctions, and trained personnel. Even when individual installations can be replaced, restoring coordination between detection, command, and interception remains a more complex task.

Reports of an incident in the Leningrad region during the drone attack on November 11 illustrate these risks. Russian air defence systems may have mistakenly struck their own helicopters and an aircraft. Although the details and scale of the reported losses remain unconfirmed, the incident points to the potential consequences of coordination failures during large-scale air attacks. Such incidents also increase the risk that Russia will lose additional military equipment while attempting to protect its own territory.

Military aviation faces similar constraints. The production of combat aircraft, engines, and onboard systems requires long industrial cycles and access to advanced technologies. Losses of experienced crews also cannot be quickly replaced. Meanwhile, the existing fleet must support operations at the front, intercept aerial targets, and patrol increasingly vulnerable rear areas. These competing tasks further limit the resources available for each mission.

The pressure on military resources coincides with growing risks to Russia’s export infrastructure. The economy remains heavily dependent on energy exports and the uninterrupted operation of major transport hubs. Ukrainian strikes on the Novatek terminal facilities, Ust-Luga Oil, and associated port and railway infrastructure on the Baltic coast during the night of November 11 demonstrated the vulnerability of these assets. The attacks followed the failure of October discussions on a possible moratorium on strikes against energy infrastructure.

Even local damage to major export facilities creates several additional costs for Moscow. Russia must finance repairs, redirect air defense systems to protect economic infrastructure, and manage the risk of disruptions to export logistics. This places further pressure on public finances and forces the state to distribute limited resources between military operations, infrastructure protection, and the maintenance of export revenues.


NATO’s Defence Production Expansion Changes the Long-Term Balance

While Russian industry faces the combined task of meeting current military demand and replacing battlefield losses, NATO countries are moving towards a more systematic expansion of defence production. The November 10 meeting in Brussels between NATO, member states, and defence industry representatives, together with Secretary General Mark Rutte’s emphasis on long-range precision systems, highlighted this shift. The discussion increasingly focuses on joint procurement and the expansion of production capacity for cruise missiles, drones, and naval strike systems.

This approach changes the conditions of long-term military planning. Joint orders provide defence companies with more predictable demand and create incentives to expand production lines. They also reduce reliance on separate national procurement programs and allow countries to coordinate investment in capabilities that would otherwise develop at different speeds.

The process requires significant investment and time. However, its strategic importance lies in the transition from identifying military requirements to building the industrial capacity needed to meet them on a sustained basis. For Russia, this creates an additional challenge. The expansion of NATO’s long-range strike capabilities increases the number of Russian military and industrial facilities that could fall within potential strike range. These include command centres, air bases, ammunition depots, and defence industry plants. Protecting them places further demands on an already stretched air defence network.

China’s military-industrial and technological expansion adds another dimension to this imbalance. Beijing is not directly involved in a military confrontation with Russia, but its growing production capacity changes the global distribution of industrial and technological resources. Russia’s reliance on Chinese components, machine tools, and electronics has become increasingly important as access to Western technologies remains restricted. This dependence limits Moscow’s ability to develop an independent technological base and maintain parity with leading military powers.

The Kremlin’s original calculation relied on the expectation that a prolonged war would exhaust Ukraine and weaken Western political support faster than it would deplete Russia’s own resources. NATO’s defence production expansion complicates this assumption. Continued Russian aggression is encouraging the Alliance to convert its economic and industrial advantages into sustained weapons production. Russia, by contrast, must replace inherited stockpiles while operating under technological restrictions and competing demands on its industrial capacity.

As Soviet-era reserves decline, the difference between Russia’s ability to sustain current operations and NATO’s capacity to expand production gains critical significance. The longer the confrontation continues, the greater the pressure on Russia to compensate for its industrial and technological limitations. This creates an incentive for Moscow to seek political arrangements that could slow down the military development of its opponents.


Moscow Seeks to Convert Military Pressure into Political Guarantees

Against this background, the Kremlin is attempting to turn its military demands into long-term political restrictions on Ukraine and NATO. Its insistence that Ukrainian forces withdraw from the part of Donetsk region still under Kyiv’s control, that Ukraine abandon its NATO membership ambitions, and that Russia receive written security guarantees goes beyond the immediate question of ending hostilities. Taken together, these demands seek to establish a security order in Europe that limits Ukraine’s ability to defend itself and restricts NATO’s military development along its eastern flank.

The emphasis on security guarantees reflects Russia’s attempt to secure through diplomacy what it cannot reliably achieve through military means. Moscow faces growing difficulties in protecting its own infrastructure, replacing military equipment, and maintaining technological capabilities. Political commitments from Ukraine and Western countries could help the Kremlin constrain its opponents without having to bear the additional military and economic costs of achieving these objectives on the battlefield.

Vladimir Putin’s November 12 proposal for a humanitarian operation in Kostiantynivka, involving the United States and a five-day ceasefire for demining, fits this approach. Despite its humanitarian framing, the initiative concerns an active combat area and follows a pattern similar to the earlier operation in Oleshky, which Russian forces used to restore positions and move equipment.

By calling on Washington and European capitals to pressure Kyiv into accepting the proposal, Moscow seeks to shift responsibility for the absence of a local ceasefire onto Ukraine. At the same time, a temporary suspension of hostilities could provide Russian forces with an operational pause in a sector where such a pause may serve their immediate military interests.

The proposal therefore should not be viewed separately from Russia’s broader negotiating demands. The Kremlin’s willingness to discuss specific humanitarian arrangements does not indicate a change in its strategic objectives. Instead, Moscow is combining maximalist political demands with limited diplomatic initiatives that could reduce the immediate costs of the war, create opportunities to restore military capabilities, and restrict Ukraine’s freedom of action.

If the war continues without the political concessions Russia seeks, the combination of declining military reserves, vulnerable export infrastructure, and expanding NATO defence production will place additional pressure on Moscow’s position. Russia will have to sustain its offensive while devoting more resources to protecting its rear and compensating for industrial and technological constraints.

The Kremlin is therefore seeking to use the current diplomatic process to secure political advantages before these constraints further reduce its room for manoeuvre. Its demands for security guarantees and proposals for local ceasefires reflect an attempt to preserve the strategic conditions for continuing its confrontation with Ukraine and the West, while limiting the military capabilities available to its opponents.

Related publications

Emerging Forms of Asymmetric Confrontation in Europe
Analytics

Emerging Forms of Asymmetric Confrontation in Europe

Europe increasingly faces destabilization that falls outside conventional military conflict and traditional public security risks. Incidents in autumn 2026 point to the emergence of a new class of threats. Their targets are no longer limited to specific infrastructure facilities or information resources. Instead, they aim to undermine the overall resilience of state systems. These operations…

Emerging Forms of Asymmetric Confrontation in Europe
Kremlin Uses Negotiations to Secure the Political Gains of Its War Against Ukraine
Analytics

Kremlin Uses Negotiations to Secure the Political Gains of Its War Against Ukraine

Ahead of a possible resumption of talks with Ukraine and the United States, the Kremlin shows no willingness to revise its war aims. Instead, Russian leaders continue to present the situation on the battlefield as a gradual move towards victory. They seek to convince Ukraine and its partners that further resistance will only weaken Kyiv’s…

Kremlin Uses Negotiations to Secure the Political Gains of Its War Against Ukraine
AfD Uses Pro-Russian Rhetoric to Gain Political Influence in Germany
Analytics

AfD Uses Pro-Russian Rhetoric to Gain Political Influence in Germany

Growing support for Alternative for Germany (AfD) gives Russia new opportunities to influence politics in one of the European Union’s most influential member states. The party has its own political agenda, but its positions on sanctions, military aid to Ukraine, energy cooperation, and relations with Moscow align with the Kremlin’s key foreign policy interests. This…

AfD Uses Pro-Russian Rhetoric to Gain Political Influence in Germany
Russia Seeks Alternative Geopolitical Alliances as International Isolation Deepens
Analytics

Russia Seeks Alternative Geopolitical Alliances as International Isolation Deepens

The narrowing scope for traditional diplomacy is pushing the Russian leadership to rely on selective channels of cooperation to maintain its international presence. Due to persistent disagreements regarding the war and uncertain terms for peace, Moscow has failed to transform its dialogue with Washington into a stable mechanism for advancing its foreign policy goals. Under…

Russia Seeks Alternative Geopolitical Alliances as International Isolation Deepens